As a director, I can honestly say that consistency matters more to me than the method. Band size, school size, "hybrid" model - if we could just use the same system across the state, I believe a lot of directors would breathe a sigh of relief. Same for the judges sheets.
We don't ask our football or volleyball teams to play by different rules each week. Why should marching bands be classified and evaluated by different standards based on where they are performing?
I would be extremely happy if contest hosts could come to some sort of agreement that provides consitency in classification, judging sheets and scoring. Competition Suite seems to gaining more traction with local competitions - that's good. Ease of access and consitency means more usable data for directors and students.
Maybe if we can get consistent classification and judging FIRST - a true statewide system/championship could be more easily adopted.