I've seen a lot of people talk about inconsistent judging during Dunlap when comparing IVC and Galesburg, but to me, looking at the individual captions, the scores seemed far too close to make the flip-flops inconsistent.
I'm probably missing something here though, so please don't hesitate to correct me if I'm wrong.
Yeah, I'd agree that those are quite high. Every band except for Anna-Jonesboro had Visual GE scores that are considerably higher than their Visual Ensemble scores, whereas last year it was the opposite. Last year the range in Visual GE was a 70-165, this year it's 140-184. Probably should be somewhere in the middle, from a 100ish-155ish.
I guess I didn’t realize IVC was doing so well considering they started the season at Washington with a 62 compared to Galesburg’s 70. Looks like the judges had mixed feelings in every caption.
I saw a video of Galesburg somewhere before results came out and I thought surely they had won.
Bravo for that upset!
Lincoln-Way Tentative schedule as of Sept 20
Herscher
Coal City
W.H Talf
Bremen
Wauwatosa West
Providence Catholic
Lemont
Rock Island
Alan B. Shepherd
Carl Sandburg
I.V. Central
Pike
Batavia
Victor J Andrew
Lake Park
Huntley
Bloomington
Marian Catholic
Plainfield Central
Prospect
Lockport
John Hersey
Morton
LWMB
I really like Batavia's show, "On Top of Spaghetti." Their performance scores at VJA weren't great, but their general effect scores were 2nd overall on the day.
If they can up the performance scores, I'm all for them taking the "cheesiest design but can play their butts off" mantle previously held by Naperville North.
Robinson Schedule:
1A:
1:15 Oblong
1:30 Arcola
1:45 Richland County
2:00 BREAK
2A:
2:15 Newton
2:30 Paris
2:45 Carterville
3:00 Marion
3:15 BREAK
3:30 Robinson (Exhibition)
3:45 Awards
I found this schedule on Richland County's band website (rchsbands.net), it is current as of 9/12.